Top 5 Myths About Replacing Your Roof: Debunked!

Replacing a roof is an eventual expense for homeowners. However, the many misconceptions and myths that surround roof replacements can often lead to unnecessary worry and stress. In this post, we’ll clear up the top 5 most common myths about roof replacements, so that you can approach the process with more confidence and knowledge.

Myth 1: Replacing Your Roof Takes Forever

Myth 1 - Replacing Your Roof

In many cases, an average roof replacement takes as little as one day.

One of the most prevalent misconceptions about replacing your roof is the belief that they are excessively time-consuming. However, this is simply not true when you hire a reputable roofing contractor. The process of a roof replacement typically involves demolition, necessary repairs to the main roofing structure, and the installation of new materials such as underlayment, flashing, and shingles. While this may initially seem like a significant undertaking, proficient roofers bring a fully equipped team of highly trained professionals who are ready to efficiently complete the job. It is not uncommon for a roof replacement to be finished in as little as a single day!

There are, of course, exceptions based on the size of the roof and the temperature at the time of installation. If it is too cold, the sealants may not adhere properly, causing delays. Even in such cases, a proficient roofer should only require a few additional days to complete the project. If a roofer quotes you a timeline of a week or even multiple weeks for a roof replacement, it could be a significant red flag. This may indicate that they are struggling to assemble a reliable crew or that their organizational and scheduling skills are lacking.

Myth 2: Replacements are Messy

Myth 2 - Replacing Your Roof

A quality roofer should leave a clean worksite and handle all the dumping or removal of construction materials.

There is a common misconception about replacing your roof, suggesting that they will leave your home and yard in disarray. While it is true that some debris and clutter may be present during the process, experienced roofers come prepared with tarps, disposal dumpsters, and all the necessary equipment to ensure a safe and clean job site. It is important to note that the roof replacement process typically takes only a few days, including the clean-up phase. The cleanliness of the job site directly impacts the time required for clean-up and the overall duration of the project, affecting labor costs for the roofer. Therefore, maintaining a clean job site is not only beneficial but also indicative of excellent workmanship and a competent roofer.

Myth 3: Insurance Will Never Cover a Roof Replacement

Many homeowners mistakenly assume that they are solely responsible for the entire cost of a roof replacement. However, this is not always the case. Depending on your insurance policy and the roofing contractor you choose to work with, your homeowners’ insurance may cover the expenses of a complete roof replacement.

Most insurance policies provide coverage for damage caused by wind, snow, hail, or rain. If your policy includes these coverage types and your roof has sustained damage from any of these events, there is a possibility that your homeowners’ insurance will cover some or all of the repair costs. To begin the process, an independent roof inspection is crucial. This inspection provides you with solid evidence beyond what the insurance adjuster determines when they visit your home.

A professional roofer will thoroughly examine your roof and provide a detailed report on the extent of the damage and the most suitable course of action. If a complete replacement is recommended, the roofer can submit this report, along with a quote, to your homeowners’ insurance company for review. Likely, your insurance company will initially dispute the claim, but having a knowledgeable roofer by your side can be invaluable throughout the process. They can even conduct tests, such as a brittle test, to substantiate their claim. With a reputable roofer advocating on your behalf, there is a higher chance of successfully obtaining a new roof through your insurance coverage.

Myth 4: You Only Have to Replace Your Roof Every 20 Years

Myth 4 - Replacing Your Roof

Many roofers promise 20+ years but in reality a improperly maintained roof could last less than 10 years.

There’s a popular idea that a roof only needs to be replaced every two decades or so. While it’s true that roofs can last around that long, to be honest, most roofs will likely not make it that long.

A few crucial things that will reduce the lifespan of your roof:

  • Inferior craftsmanship
  • Low-quality shingles
  • Insufficient use of flashings
  • Overuse of sealant as a shortcut
  • Absence of ice shield
  • Impact of heavy debris on the roof
  • Exposure to cold temperatures or severe weather conditions
  • Re-roofing without removing existing shingles
  • Neglecting roof inspections every 5 years
  • Presence of mold, algae, or moss on the roof.

If one or more of these issues are present, a roof that was expected to last 20 years often struggles to make it past 5. Unfortunately, these issues are more common than we would like, and it ultimately boils down to the crucial task of hiring a high-quality roofer. If you happen to notice any of these problems, it is advisable not to rehire the roofer who initially installed your roof and instead seek out the most exceptional roofer available in your area.

Myth 5: You Can Just Reshingle Over Your Shingles to Save Money

It may save you money in the short term but an extra layer of shingle adds weight and in many cases is covering up real issues that will cost you dearly.

Many homeowners mistakenly believe that they can save money by simply adding new shingles over their existing ones. However, this is a highly ill-advised approach! Not only is it in violation of building codes in many areas, but it can also lead to more severe damage in the future. When you add new shingles on top of old ones, each nail used by the roofer creates a potential entry point for moisture. Moreover, over time, the nails from the previous installation can gradually shift upward due to the weight of the double roof, causing damage and creating holes in the top layer of shingles. Consequently, water can infiltrate the roofing structure, resulting in a myriad of problems down the line.

Another significant concern is that when roofers simply place new shingles over the existing ones, they may overlook underlying problems. They might miss leaks, moisture issues, and other pressing issues. Consequently, although your roof may appear visually appealing, severe problems could develop and manifest themselves later on.

If you find yourself in need of a roof replacement, it is strongly recommended to proceed with a full tear-off rather than attempting a quick fix that may only exacerbate the issue.

Worried? Trust a Good Roofer for a Roof Replacement

By dispelling these common misconceptions about replacing your roof, we aim to demystify the process for you. Keep in mind that replacing your roof is not only an investment in your home but also in your safety. It is crucial to approach this endeavor with careful thought and consideration. If you are contemplating a roof replacement, don’t hesitate to seek the assistance of experienced professionals who can guide you through the process and help you make informed decisions for the well-being of your home and your family.

If you’re located in Tennessee or Georgia, then Roof MD can help! We offer FREE Roof Inspection & Estimates, so book yours today below.